SOL – “As the action is time-barred, it cannot be commenced again and the controversy therefore has reached an ultimate outcome.”

A Sydney Sullivan Report

Source: Stopforeclosurefraud – HSBC v CLARK-MOORE | NY SC – As this action is time-barred, it cannot be commenced again and the controversy has therefore reached an ultimate outcome. 

ExpiredThis is a most interesting case. Statutes of limitations exist for both civil and criminal causes of action, and begin to run from the date of the injury, or the date it was discovered, or the date on which it would have been discovered with reasonable efforts. In foreclosure cases there have been controversies stemming at times from the games the servicers play with “trial” payments and modifications.

Many statutes of limitations are actual legislative statutes, while others may come from judicial common law. Source: Cornell University Law School, Legal Information Institute. Both federal and state have various statutes and federal bankruptcy statutes of limitations that may even trump the others.

Here, in CLARK-MOORE, the Supreme Court of the State of New York clarified several controversies found in other circuits by specifying precisely when the SOL begins, “by the commencement of the first action” simply stating:

Fel Moore SOL

The Supreme Courts refers to UMLIC VP, LLC v. MELLACE, 19 A.D.3d 684 (2005) where it notes that “the Supreme Court correctly determined that the mere acceptance of a partial payment of the accelerated debt by the previous holder of the subject note was not an affirmative act revoking the acceleration and thereby halting the running of the statute of limitations (see Lavin v. Elmakiss, 302 A.D.2d 638 [2003]).”

Lavin details the difference between unpaid installments and acceleration.

The six-year statute of limitations in a mortgage foreclosure action begins to run from the due date for each unpaid installment unless the debt has been accelerated; once the debt has been accelerated by a demand or commencement of an action, the entire sum becomes due and the statute of limitations begins to run on the entire mortgage (see Loiacono v Goldberg240 A.D.2d 476, 477; see also CPLR 213 [4]; Saini v Cinelli Enters.289 A.D.2d 770, 771, lv denied 98 N.Y.2d 602).”

Gavel and old clockMany courts look at the four or six year period, depending upon the state, as the final statutory time, i.e. as in an “action may be commenced at any time within six years after the person who is entitled to bring the same discovers or should have discovered, the existence of the cause of action.” Basically, it appears this is saying to the litigator, if you knew or should have known from your first blush, there were 4-6 years from the cause to commence an action – thereafter, the attorneys advise us, you are likely too late – SOL.

As Justice Hinrichs pens in Clark-Moore,

“As the action is time-barred, it cannot be commenced again and the controversy therefore has reached an ultimate outcome.”

It’s a good case to read, dissect and research noted case law. See StopForeclosureFraud for a copy of the Order on Scribd.

2 thoughts on “SOL – “As the action is time-barred, it cannot be commenced again and the controversy therefore has reached an ultimate outcome.”

  1. Dear Sir,

    Thank you sooo very much for keep fighting for us! Love you!
    Unfortunately, my World Savings/Wachovia/Wells Fart Go loan have been mediated almost 8 years I was told the Wells Fart Go rejected our AG office also, they said it was due to I didn’t have so much money in my account after all these years without paying the loan.

    When i clicked HICKS vs WELLS FARGO BANK | FL 5DCA – the complaint was time barred and must be dismissed with prejudice because the suit was not commenced within five years of the default date alleged in the complaint IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF…
    Then I get:
    Your access to this site has been limited
    Your access to this service has been temporarily limited. Please try again in a few minutes. (HTTP response code 503)
    Reason: Advanced blocking in effect.
    Important note for site admins: If you are the administrator of this website note that your access has been limited because you broke one of the Wordfence firewall rules. The reason you access was limited is: “Advanced blocking in effect.”. 

If this is a false positive, meaning that your access to your own site has been limited incorrectly, then you will need to regain access to your site, go to the Wordfence “options” page, go to the section for Firewall Rules and disable the rule that caused you to be blocked. For example, if you were blocked because it was detected that you are a fake Google crawler, then disable the rule that blocks fake google crawlers. Or if you were blocked because you were accessing your site too quickly, then increase the number of accesses allowed per minute. 

If you’re still having trouble, then simply disable the Wordfence firewall and you will still benefit from the other security features that Wordfence provides. 

If you are a site administrator and have been accidentally locked out, please enter your email in the box below and click “Send”. If the email address you enter belongs to a known site administrator or someone set to receive Wordfence alerts, we will send you an email to help you regain access. Please read this FAQ entry if this does not work. 

    I don’t know why. I have the Fart Go bank and have been going through “mediation” for 8 years, still doesn’t go anywhere, the day before just refused AG office request for the loan mod too, even though my interests has been 6.49% for many years. The bank really knows what it’s doing. – the Fart Go told AG office they don’t see I have so much money in the bank, and also my NPV is not qualified.
    All of this even after 2 badface certificates, doesn’t matter; the World Savings cheated me, doesn’t matter… all doesn’t matter, what matters is the bank wants to refuse my loan mod! 
Thank you,


    • Try to get whatever current process is active dismissed, on any grounds (not SOL). Then, any subsequent suit would be barred as time-limited, assuming 8 years have passed since acceleration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s